Funnel Plot for brma Object

funnel.brma creates a funnel plot for a fitted brma object. For intercept-only models without scale regression, the default outcome mode displays observed effect sizes against the fitted sampling distribution. For models with location or scale moderators, the default residual mode displays residuals against a standard-error funnel.

Usage

# S3 method for class 'brma'
funnel(
  x,
  residual,
  type = "LOO-PIT",
  unit = "estimate",
  conditioning_depth = "marginal",
  sampling_heterogeneity = TRUE,
  sampling_bias = TRUE,
  max_samples = 10000,
  plot_type = "base",
  ...
)

Arguments

x

a fitted brma object

residual

whether to use residual mode. Defaults to not specified, which means the function automatically determines the mode:

not specified: For intercept-only models without scale regression, displays observed effect sizes against the fitted sampling distribution funnel; for models with moderators or scale regression, automatically uses residual mode.
FALSE: explicitly requests outcome mode.
TRUE: explicitly requests residual mode, displaying residuals on the x-axis and using type to determine how those residuals are computed.

type

the type of residuals to use when in residual mode. Options are:

"LOO-PIT" (alias: "rstudent"; default): Leave-one-out probability integral transform residuals returned by rstudent.brma.
"rstandard": Internally standardized residuals using rstandard.brma. Only available for normal outcome models.
"outcome": Raw outcome residuals from residuals.brma with type = "outcome".

Only used when funnel is in residual mode.

unit

output unit for residual mode. Only "estimate" is implemented in this pass.

conditioning_depth

residual conditioning depth for residual mode. Options are "marginal", "cluster", and "estimate". The default LOO-PIT residual path is available only with marginal conditioning depth.

sampling_heterogeneity

whether heterogeneity should be incorporated into the sampling distribution funnel. Defaults to TRUE. Only used in outcome mode and ignored in residual mode.

sampling_bias

whether publication bias should be incorporated into the sampling distribution funnel. Defaults to TRUE. Only used when residual = FALSE or when automatic mode selects outcome mode. Ignored in residual mode. When TRUE and the model includes selection models (weightfunction), uses selected-normal quantiles. When TRUE and the model includes PET/PEESE, incorporates the expected skew from these regression adjustments.

max_samples

maximum number of posterior samples used for model-averaged publication-bias funnel contours. Defaults to 10000. Use Inf to use all posterior samples.

plot_type

whether to use a base plot "base" or ggplot2 "ggplot" for plotting. Defaults to "base".

...

additional graphical arguments to customize the plot appearance:

xlim, ylim: numeric vectors of length 2 specifying axis limits
xlab, ylab: character strings for axis labels
main: character string for plot title (default: no title)
pch: point symbol (default: 21, filled circle). Use standard R pch values.
col: point border color (default: "black")
bg: point fill/background color (default: "#A6A6A6")
cex: point size multiplier for base graphics (default: 1)
size: point size for ggplot2 (default: 2)
las: axis-label style for base graphics (default: 1)
back: background region color (default: "grey"). Set to NA to suppress.
shade: funnel region fill color (default: "white"). Set to NA to suppress.
lty: line type for funnel edges and center line (default: "dotted")
col.line: color for funnel edge lines (default: "black")
refline: numeric override for the reference line. By default, residual mode uses 0, while outcome mode uses the center of the fitted sampling distribution, which may be curved when PET/PEESE bias adjustment is incorporated.
col.refline: color of vertical reference line (default: "black")
as_data: if TRUE, returns plot data instead of creating a plot

Value

If as_data = TRUE, funnel.brma returns a list with the data used for plotting, including the plotted points, funnel polygons, plotting limits, labels, and reference line. Otherwise, it returns NULL invisibly if plot_type = "base" or a ggplot object if plot_type = "ggplot".

Details

The funnel plot has two modes. If residual is not specified, the mode is chosen automatically from the fitted model: intercept-only models without scale regression use outcome mode, whereas models with location or scale moderators use residual mode.

Outcome mode (intercept-only models without scale regression): Displays observed effect sizes on the x-axis and standard errors on the y-axis. The reference line follows the center of the fitted sampling distribution. When sampling_bias = FALSE, this center is the pooled effect; when PET/PEESE bias adjustment is incorporated, the center line can vary with the standard error. The funnel region represents the central 95\ region of the sampling distribution, optionally incorporating heterogeneity and publication bias.

Residual mode (models with moderators or scale regression): Displays residuals on the x-axis and standard errors on the y-axis. The funnel region represents the central 95\ \(N(0, \mathrm{SE}^2)\). With type = "LOO-PIT", the plotted residuals and standard errors are the raw-scale LOO predictive companions returned by rstudent.brma; the PIT-normalized z values are used by qqnorm.brma and influence diagnostics. With type = "rstandard", the plotted values are internally standardized residual companions from rstandard.brma. With type = "outcome", these are raw outcome residuals. Under a correctly specified model, most points should fall within this region.

The type argument controls how residuals are computed in residual mode. See residuals.brma for details on each type. The sampling_heterogeneity and sampling_bias arguments are ignored in residual mode.

For GLMM models, observed effect sizes are computed from the raw frequency data using formulas equivalent to metafor::escalc. Residual-mode GLMM funnels use approximate effect-size-scale residual/PIT companions, not exact PIT diagnostics for the raw count likelihood.

Examples

if (FALSE) { # \dontrun{
if (requireNamespace("metadat", quietly = TRUE) &&
    requireNamespace("metafor", quietly = TRUE)) {
  data(dat.bcg, package = "metadat")
  dat <- metafor::escalc(
    measure = "RR",
    ai      = tpos,
    bi      = tneg,
    ci      = cpos,
    di      = cneg,
    data    = dat.bcg
  )

  fit <- brma(yi = yi, vi = vi, data = dat, measure = "RR")
  funnel(fit)
  funnel(fit, pch = 19, col = "blue", bg = "lightblue")

  fit_reg <- brma(
    yi      = yi,
    vi      = vi,
    mods    = ~ ablat + year,
    data    = dat,
    measure = "RR"
  )
  fit_reg <- add_loo(fit_reg)
  funnel(fit_reg)
  funnel(fit_reg, type = "outcome")

  funnel_data <- funnel(fit, as_data = TRUE)
  funnel(fit, plot_type = "ggplot")
}
} # }

Usage

Arguments

Value

Details

See also

Examples